OpinionBuying advice

Disc vs rim brakes: does it still matter which you choose?

The real differences between disc and rim brakes, who might still prefer rim brakes, and why we think discs are the right choice for most riders.

Close-up of a disc brake rotor on a bike's front wheel
Photo: CHUTTERSNAP on Unsplash

Some links on this page are affiliate links. If you buy through one we may earn a small commission, at no extra cost to you. It never changes how we rank. How we make money.

Not long ago, the disc versus rim brake debate split road cyclists down the middle. Today, almost every new road and gravel bike comes with disc brakes. But rim brakes have not disappeared, and some brands still offer them. So does it still matter which you choose?

How they differ

Rim brakes squeeze pads against the rim of the wheel. They have been around for as long as bikes have, and are simple and light.

Disc brakes squeeze pads against a metal rotor fixed to the wheel hub. They come in two types. Hydraulic discs use fluid to push the pads and give the most power and control. Mechanical discs use a cable and are cheaper, but usually less powerful and need more adjustment.

The case for discs

Better in the wet. This is the big one. Rim brakes work on a surface covered in water and road grit, so they lose a lot of power in the rain. Discs sit away from the road spray and stop far more consistently. In a British winter, that difference is huge.

More control. Hydraulic discs need only a light pull on the lever, which helps on long descents and for riders with smaller hands.

Wider tyres. Without a rim brake calliper in the way, frames can take much wider tyres. That brings comfort and grip, as we explain in our tyres guide.

Rims last longer. Rim brakes slowly wear away the wheel rims. Disc brakes wear the much cheaper rotors and pads instead.

The case for rim brakes

Lighter. A rim brake bike is usually a little lighter.

Simpler. Rim brakes are easy to adjust, easy to fix at the roadside and there is no fluid to bleed.

Cheaper to maintain. Pads are cheap and there are no rotors to replace.

Classic looks. Some riders simply prefer the clean, traditional look of a rim brake bike.

Who might still choose rim brakes

A rim brake bike can still make sense if you mostly ride in dry weather, want the lightest and simplest bike possible, or love a classic steel road bike. A few brands still make new ones for exactly these riders.

Our verdict

For most people, disc brakes are the better choice. They are safer in the wet, give you room for wider tyres and are now standard on almost every new bike. If you are choosing between discs, go hydraulic if you can. Mechanical discs work, but they are a step down.

If you are comparing bikes, our road bike buying guide covers what else to look for.

More from GearRatio

Further reading from around the web

Pieces we rate from other UK cycling publishers. They open on the publisher's site.